Cape Coral Restaurants
Seafood

No matter which seafood restaurant you try in Cape Coral and the surrounding areas, grouper will usually be your freshest fish – and it is delicious.

Our favorite places to order seafood are Anthony’s, Snug Harbor and the Matanzas Inn on Ft. Myers Beach. There is a outdoor bar- like restaurant on Ft. Myers Beach too called Smokin Oyster Bar that our friends from Denver couldn’t get enough of and we enjoy.

Anthony's On The Gulf
3040 Estero Blvd
Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931
(239) 463-2600

Matanzas Inn
(239) 463-3838
416 Crescent St
Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931

Smokin Oyster Brewery
(239) 463-3474
340 Old San Carlos Blvd
Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931

Snug Harbor Waterfront Restaurant
(239) 463-4343
1131 1st St
Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931

We tried Red’s once after we moved to Key West (fresh seafood Mecca – here for two years while my husband attends nursing school) and weren’t impressed – but we are admittedly spoiled and our guests really do rave about that one. The Prawnbroker is another one our guests love – but we didn’t like the atmosphere the one time we tried it– seemed too much like a New York hustle to us - like they were trying to turn the tables and just wanted us out of there. Granted, we went during the busy season, but still – it wasn’t cheap enough to tolerate that treatment.

Prawnbroker Restaurant & Fish
13451 Mcgregor Blvd # 16
Fort Myers, FL 33919
(239) 489-2226

Red's Fresh Seafood House
10880 Stringfellow Rd
Bokeelia, FL 33922
(239) 283-4412

If you want to cook it at home, try the fresh fish market on 47th Terrace one block north of Cape Coral Parkway. They have great fish kabobs ready to toss on the grill. Yum!

A & R Food Meat Market
(239) 540-8183
516 SE 47th Ter
Cape Coral, FL

CAUTION: Like many coastal areas, Cape Coral occasionally experiences what is known as a “red tide”. During such periods (twice since in my recollection since owning Cape Coral real estate), do not eat locally caught shellfish such as clams. Ingestion of shellfish contaminated by red tide can result in serious injury and/or death. As an ER nurse, I have seen the affects of this first hand and would not wish them on anyone. Check local TV news broadcasts and or the local newspaper for red tide conditions that may occur during your visit.

Return to Cape Coral Restaurant Guide from Cape Coral Restaurants Seafood

Return to Cape Coral Vacation Guide